Essa é uma revisão anterior do documento!


Artigo

Informações gerais

  1. Título: Uma avaliação do estimador de pseudo-verossimilhança para modelos autologísticos espaciais
  2. Autores:
  3. Periódico:

Submissão inicial

  1. Versões preliminares do texto:
    • artigo2 (Denise, 08/02/2007)
    • artigo2 em PDF e artigo 2 tem TEX (Clarice, 11/02/2007, 13:48)
    • artigo2, primeira parte (1/3), revisado por PJ (PJ, 12/02/2007, 15:35)
    • artigo2, segunda parte (2/3), revisado por PJ (PJ, 12/02/2007, 20:10)
    • artigo2, terceira parte (3/3), revisado por PJ (PJ, 12/02/2007, 23:30)
  2. Texto Submetido:

Referee Reports

Referee 1

The paper is very interesting and I recommend the publication in RME provided some corrections are made. Most of the corrections are indicated directly in the manuscript. Special attention must be given to the section “Resultados e Discussão”, where results are basicallydescribed, without a discussion. Furthermore references must follow the journal normatization.

Authors discussions/coments
  • PJ (21/02/2008): Denise and Clarice have revised the manuscript following the comments written by this referee. I believe there is no action needed from PJ and/or Brian here, unless Clarice and Denise say otherwise.

Referee 2

The authors study, using simulations, the propertiesof the pseudo-maximum likelihood estimator for the autologistic regression model. The simulations cover scenarios with two covariates with and without correlation among them and also with and without spatial correlation. Differesnt probability of success for each plant was considered (low, medium and high infestation) and also the autocorrelation parameter γ as varied. An numerical illustration is also provided with data from plant disease.

References – Denise add the PDF files below

  • Johansson (2001)
  • Jensen and Kunsch (1994)
  • Jensen and Moller (2001)
  • Baddeley and Tirner (2000)
  • Biggeri et. al. (2003)

Revisão do artigo

  1. Revisões no texto após comentários dos revisores:
    1. Revisão Denise 19/08/2007, 21:45

QR Code
QR Code pessoais:denise:artigo2 (generated for current page)