Você está aqui: start » artigos » ernesto2

Diferenças

Aqui você vê as diferenças entre duas revisões dessa página.

Link para esta página de comparações

Ambos lados da revisão anteriorRevisão anterior
Próxima revisão		Revisão anterior
artigos:ernesto2 [2008/02/21 19:00] – paulojusartigos:ernesto2 [2008/02/26 18:53] (atual) – ernesto
Linha 14: Linha 14:
     * [[http://www.icm.csic.es/scimar/|Scientia Marina]]     * [[http://www.icm.csic.es/scimar/|Scientia Marina]]
       * submetido em 23/10/2007. {{artigos:ernesto2:ejpj_cexp07.pdf|Texto submetido}}        * submetido em 23/10/2007. {{artigos:ernesto2:ejpj_cexp07.pdf|Texto submetido}} 
 +
  
 ===== Submissão para Scientia Marina (aceito - minor changes) ===== ===== Submissão para Scientia Marina (aceito - minor changes) =====
Linha 19: Linha 20:
     * {{artigos:sm2593.tar.gz|arquivos fonte}}     * {{artigos:sm2593.tar.gz|arquivos fonte}}
     * Referees reports: {{artigos:ernesto2:sm2593referee1.doc|Referee 1}} e {{artigos:ernesto2:sm2593referee2.doc|Referee 2}} (the texts are also copied below)      * Referees reports: {{artigos:ernesto2:sm2593referee1.doc|Referee 1}} e {{artigos:ernesto2:sm2593referee2.doc|Referee 2}} (the texts are also copied below) 
 +    * Artigo resubmetido após sugestões dos revisores
 +      - arquivo PDF (FAZER UPLOAD AQUI)
 +      - arquivos FONTE (FAZER UPLOAD AQUI)
     * Resposta dos editores (aceitação com "minor changes"):     * Resposta dos editores (aceitação com "minor changes"):
  
Linha 76: Linha 80:
  
 //Literature cited// //Literature cited//
-  * Doonan, I.J., B. Bull and R.F. Coombs. (2003). Star acoustic surveys of localized fish aggregations. ICES J. Mar. Sci. , 60: 132-146.+  * Doonan, I.J., B. Bull and R.F. Coombs. (2003). Star acoustic surveys of localized fish aggregations. ICES J. Mar. Sci. , 60:132-146.
   * Petitgas, P. (2001). Geostatistics in fisheries survey design and stock assement: models, variances and applications. Fish Fish., 2:231-249.    * Petitgas, P. (2001). Geostatistics in fisheries survey design and stock assement: models, variances and applications. Fish Fish., 2:231-249. 
- * Rufino, M.M., V. Stelzenmüller, F.Maynou and G.P.Zauke (2006). Assessing the performance of linear geostatistical tools applied to artificial fisheries data. Fisheries Research 82 (1-3): 263-279 +  * Rufino, M.M., V. Stelzenmüller, F. Maynou and G.P. Zauke (2006). Assessing the performance of linear geostatistical tools applied to artificial fisheries data. Fisheries Research 82 (1-3):263-279 
-  * Simard, Y., P. Legendre, G. Lavoie and D. Marcotte. (1992). Mapping, estimating biomass, and optimizing sampling programs for spatially autocorrelated data: case study of the northern shrimp (Pandalus borealis). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 49: 32-45. +  * Simard, Y., P. Legendre, G. Lavoie and D. Marcotte. (1992). Mapping, estimating biomass, and optimizing sampling programs for spatially autocorrelated data: case study of the northern shrimp (Pandalus borealis). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 49:32-45. 
-  * Stelzenmüller, V., S. Ehrich and G.-P. Zauke. (2005). Impact of additional small-scale catch data (star survey design) on the geostatistical analyses of demersal fish species in the North Sea. Scientia Marina, 69 (4): 587-602.+  * Stelzenmüller, V., S. Ehrich and G.P. Zauke. (2005). Impact of additional small-scale catch data (star survey design) on the geostatistical analyses of demersal fish species in the North Sea. Scientia Marina, 69 (4): 587-602.
  
 +== Reply to referee 1 ==
 +
 +{{artigos:sm2593_reply_referee1.odt|OpenOffice doc}}
 +
 +{{artigos:sm2593_reply_referee1.pdf|pdf}}
  
 === Referee 2 === === Referee 2 ===
Linha 93: Linha 102:
   - Page 7, line 178-179, do you mean “hybrid design had lower sill and range”?   - Page 7, line 178-179, do you mean “hybrid design had lower sill and range”?
   - Page 8, although the results presented in the paper are useful and informative, a better comparison could be made by estimating the covariance parameters using the pooled observations, and do conditional simulation with the pooled parameter estimators to compare the two designs.   - Page 8, although the results presented in the paper are useful and informative, a better comparison could be made by estimating the covariance parameters using the pooled observations, and do conditional simulation with the pooled parameter estimators to compare the two designs.
 +
 +== Reply to referee 2 ==
 +
 +{{artigos:sm2593_reply_referee2.odt|OpenOffice doc}}
 +
 +{{artigos:sm2593_reply_referee2.pdf|pdf}}
  
 ===== Submissão para Fisheries Research (rejeitado) ===== ===== Submissão para Fisheries Research (rejeitado) =====
Linha 191: Linha 206:
  In the light of the many comments made by the reviewers I conclude with regret that this manuscript is not acceptabe as it stands.Questions on the paucity of the data, the lack of statistical power, difficulty of generalising the results, and the possibility of redundancy with other papers are only some of the matters raised. However, there is good material in this manuscript, and if the authors are able to take full account of the reviewers concerns, a resubmission is possible.  In the light of the many comments made by the reviewers I conclude with regret that this manuscript is not acceptabe as it stands.Questions on the paucity of the data, the lack of statistical power, difficulty of generalising the results, and the possibility of redundancy with other papers are only some of the matters raised. However, there is good material in this manuscript, and if the authors are able to take full account of the reviewers concerns, a resubmission is possible.
  
-===== Resubmissão =====+===== Resubmissão para Fisheries Research (TB REJEITADO...) =====
  
 Idéia básica ao redor da sugestao do segundo referee de enfatizar a metodologia, eventualmente em maiores detalhes Idéia básica ao redor da sugestao do segundo referee de enfatizar a metodologia, eventualmente em maiores detalhes

QR Code
QR Code artigos:ernesto2 (generated for current page)